Martin Weinberg is asking Judge William Sullivan to open up another piece of the Lindsay Clancy trial record—juror notes and sidebar discussions that are currently subject to impoundment. Weinberg argued for Clancy’s defense on a motion seeking an order that those materials not remain impounded. The reason matters. The defense Read more…
The detective was explaining paperwork. Search warrants, phone downloads, next steps. And Caleb Flynn interrupted him: it feels like you guys are pointing it to me. Nobody accused him. Then he added that he’d never laid a hand on his wife — an answer to a question nobody had asked. Read more…
The Lindsay Clancy Rule 25 fight took a sharp turn on September 29 when defense attorney Kevin Reddington challenged both the proof that she committed the charged acts and the Commonwealth’s case on criminal responsibility. Reddington told the court his required-finding argument has two tracks. The first reaches back to Read more…
The prosecution called forty witnesses and put 107,000 text messages in front of the jury. Caleb Flynn’s defense called zero. The messages between Caleb and his mistress Alleigha Botner were organized by the state’s digital analyst into categories. “Kill Ashley, Ashley Dead/Gone, Rid of Ashley.” “About Hating Ashley” — ninety-five Read more…
The final prosecution response in the Caleb Flynn trial focused on something simple: connect the evidence, connect the timeline, and compare both with what prosecutors characterize as Caleb’s lies. Miami County Prosecuting Attorney Paul Watkins used rebuttal to answer the defense’s argument that the State had not proved Caleb killed Read more…
The Caleb Flynn trial reached the point where the same record became two very different stories for the jury. Prosecutor Matthew Joseph told jurors the evidence against Caleb becomes overwhelming when they stop isolating each item and consider the case as a whole. Defense attorney L. Patrick Mulligan told them Read more…
The door wasn’t locked. It wasn’t even latched. But somebody pried it open anyway — and the damage was on the inside. Detective Mike Morgan told Caleb Flynn that to his face and said it didn’t make a whole lot of sense. Caleb said for sure. In Part 2 of Read more…
The detective handed Caleb Flynn’s phone back after scrolling through it and finding nothing. Not one message from his wife Ashley. Caleb had the explanation ready: he deletes texts to save storage. The jury now knows what prosecutors allege was actually on that phone. In this interrogation breakdown with retired Read more…
For a year, Caleb Flynn told his girlfriend he hated his wife and was going to leave her. Then he put a condition on it, and that condition is the part of the Caleb Flynn trial texts that tells you exactly who he is. Tony reads the message and then Read more…
There’s a message in the Caleb Flynn trial where he tells Alleigha Botner what he’ll do once Ashley is asleep, and she answers “Perfect.” It’s from September 2, 2025. Ashley Flynn was shot in her sleep on February 16, 2026. That exchange is the spine of this Hidden Killers panel, Read more…