Before the prosecution could turn Caleb Flynn’s affair into a courtroom reveal, his own defense put it in front of the jury. Emily Smith opened with a verse from Proverbs, admitted Flynn was unfaithful and Read more…
Bryan Kohberger is trying to take back his guilty plea as alleged unredacted crime-scene photos from the Idaho murders move through the online creator world. The criminal case ended in 2025, but the records around Read more…
Caleb Flynn gave police a direction before they had finished clearing his Tipp City home: look at the garage. On the 911 call placed at 2:31 a.m. February 16, Flynn said someone had broken in, Read more…
There’s a document in the Bryan Kohberger case that prosecutors never saw and the families never knew existed until September 2026. Filed under seal by his original defense team, it told the judge their client Read more…
I sat down with Eric Faddis, defense attorney and former prosecutor, on two cases. The first is the Caleb Flynn murder trial in Miami County, Ohio. Alleigha Botner, a prosecution witness and Flynn’s former girlfriend, Read more…
Det. Sgt. Mike Morgan put Caleb Flynn’s own recorded police interviews in front of the jury, including the moment Flynn told him, “It feels like you’re pointing at me.” Morgan testified about his response to Read more…
Three trustees have held Nick Reiner’s money since his parents were found dead, and each gave a different reason for keeping it. Matthew Fishburn never paid the age-30 distribution. Paul Kanin questioned Nick’s competence even Read more…
Joseph Stratman’s cameras didn’t show an outside intruder approaching the home where Alleigha Botner was house-sitting. Prosecutors instead played three surveillance clips that Stratman testified showed a car leaving, returning, and leaving again – evidence Read more…
Alleigha Botner told the jury in the Caleb Flynn trial what she was doing on her phone the night before Ashley Flynn was killed, and who she was sending it to. The former church intern Read more…
Special Agent Andrea Kinzig returned to the stand in Caleb Flynn’s trial for the murder of his wife, Ashley Flynn, and the defense zeroed in on an investigative lead that went nowhere. Kinzig testified that Read more…
Five moves, twelve months, and more than 100,000 texts — that’s what the prosecution’s central witness described from the stand as she read her own messages with Caleb Flynn to the jury. Messages that show Read more…
Special Agent Andrea Kinzig took the Caleb Flynn jury deeper into the digital evidence, and one finding widened the picture beyond Flynn and Alleigha Botner. Kinzig testified that Kayla Heyt, Ashley Flynn’s sister, abused a Read more…
Special Agent Joseph Wilhelm returned to the Caleb Flynn trial under cross-examination, and the defense aimed directly at the digital evidence extracted from the iPhones. Defense questioning framed that evidence as unreliable, challenging how much Read more…
On the last night of Ashley Flynn’s life, her husband was messaging another woman until after midnight. That’s what Alleigha Botner told the jury in the Caleb Flynn murder trial, testifying for the prosecution. She Read more…
In the Caleb Flynn murder trial, prosecutors are building motive out of what the former American Idol singer typed to the woman he was seeing. Alleigha Botner took the stand for the state and read Read more…
One juror stopped eleven others from acquitting Lindsay Clancy by reason of insanity. Now that juror is the subject of a formal judicial inquiry, and his own court records are the reason. Judge William Sullivan Read more…
Two cases. Three conversations. Prosecutors in the Caleb Flynn murder trial say the former worship pastor sent more than 100,000 messages to his mistress, some allegedly describing plans to kill his wife Ashley. At the Read more…
Special Agent Joseph Wilhelm took the Caleb Flynn jury inside the digital evidence recovered from Flynn’s iPhone, and the timeline prosecutors are building now has another layer. Wilhelm testified that Instagram, GroupMe, ChatGPT and other Read more…
The State of Indiana’s proof that Richard Allen was treated well in solitary is a short list: a free replacement tablet, a new cell window, and a couple of in-person visits with his wife. The Read more…
Alleigha Botner’s cross-examination in the Caleb Flynn murder trial gave the defense a chance to turn the spotlight onto the prosecution’s affair witness. Botner testified that she had searched the internet for information about unsolved Read more…
Bryan Kohberger admitted in July 2025 to killing Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin at an off-campus house in Moscow, Idaho. He was sentenced to four consecutive life sentences. A year later, Read more…
Alleigha Botner testified that the affair with Caleb Flynn came roaring back just before Ashley Flynn was killed. On February 14, Botner said Caleb told her he hoped their relationship was not over. By February Read more…
Alleigha Botner is the prosecution’s star witness in the Caleb Flynn murder trial. She’s also a woman who deleted evidence, lied to federal agents, and helped the defendant research how to wipe his phone — Read more…
Alleigha Botner told the Caleb Flynn jury that by late 2025, her message to Caleb had become consistent: leave Ashley Flynn, or the affair was over. Botner testified that she first set Christmas Eve as Read more…
Alleigha Botner read a message she said she sent Caleb Flynn during their affair: “I want to kill her, Caleb.” Botner testified that Caleb replied, “That makes 2 of us.” Those words were presented to Read more…
Alleigha Botner returned to the stand in Caleb Flynn’s murder trial and read more private messages between herself and Caleb. In one message attributed to Caleb, Botner testified he wrote, “Please hire someone to take Read more…
Caleb Flynn led worship at two churches for eleven years. He appeared on American Idol Season 12 and told producers on camera that he loved his wife Ashley more than anything. He was the spiritual Read more…
Prosecutors in the Caleb Flynn murder trial say the former worship pastor sent more than 100,000 messages to his mistress in the year before his wife Ashley was found shot to death inside their Tipp Read more…
Junior Burdynski was ten years old, four feet tall, and riding a red-and-white Schwinn when he disappeared from Brentwood, Maryland, on May 24, 1993. His family searched. Law enforcement brought dogs, helicopters, FBI agents going Read more…
This episode is the definitive behavioral breakdown of the Caleb Flynn murder case. Tony Brueski sits down with former FBI behavioral analyst Robin Dreeke to analyze the case across three segments, covering every major piece Read more…