Look past the verdict watch and the Lindsay Clancy case has become something much stranger. We are judging the jurors for failing to agree. We are judging Patrick Clancy for how he grieves, where he lives, whom he married and Read more…
Tyler Robinson entered a not-guilty plea after Judge Tony Graf sent the Charlie Kirk case to trial on aggravated murder and six other charges. Prosecutors say their preliminary case includes campus surveillance, a rifle recovered near the alleged escape route, Read more…
There is a persistent assumption that Lindsay Clancy rejected some compromise and forced everyone into this trial. Her lawyer says that never happened. Kevin Reddington says prosecutors did not offer a plea deal. With three first-degree murder charges, the case Read more…
Charlie Adelson’s defense at trial was that he was being extorted. A periodontist pulling in over three million a year told a jury he was so terrified of two hitmen that he set up a three-thousand-dollar monthly payment plan through Read more…
Apparently there is now an internet-approved timetable for grieving your children, and Patrick Clancy failed to consult it. Patrick eventually relocated to New York and remarried after losing Cora, Dawson and Callan. He also publicly forgave Lindsay and has described Read more…
The Lindsay Clancy jury didn’t merely deadlock. According to Kevin Reddington, its foreperson raised a problem involving one juror and the court’s reasonable-doubt instructions. Reddington wanted that juror removed. Judge William Sullivan refused, correctly noting that removing someone from a Read more…
A Massachusetts jury spent five weeks, heard from more than eighty witnesses, and still couldn’t agree on what to do with Lindsay Clancy. Now her attorney’s own attempt to fix that has become its own story. Clancy, 34, of Duxbury, Read more…
Eighty witnesses. Five weeks. Three hundred exhibits. And Lindsay Clancy’s jury still can’t agree on the one question that decides everything — was she psychotic when her three children died, or wasn’t she. Judge Sullivan gave them the Tuey-Rodriguez instruction, the Read more…
There are two timelines running through the Nolan Wells case, and they don’t match up. The first belongs to the physical evidence. Nolan’s phone has been with his family since July 5. On July 15, they agreed with the Jackson Read more…
Mica Miller called police at least seven times reporting harassment, tire slashing, and surveillance, telling officers she was afraid for her life. Every single time, her husband John-Paul Miller had already gotten to the narrative first — telling officers she Read more…
