Rob and Michele Reiner didn’t fit the profile of parents who looked the other way. They showed up. They sat in every therapy session. They wrote the checks. They flew to the facilities. They played frisbee with their son’s rehab roommate. For more than fifteen years, they did everything the Read more…
Two cases. Two sets of problems the public is not being told about. Criminal defense attorney Bob Motta joins Hidden Killers to break down the Nancy Guthrie investigation from a defense perspective and walk through what both sides are facing if the Alex Murdaugh conviction is reversed at oral arguments Read more…
The state has rested in the Paul Caneiro murder trial, and the defense has begun presenting its case in what has become one of the most closely watched trials in New Jersey history. After four weeks and fifteen days of prosecution testimony, jurors in Monmouth County have now heard from Read more…
Oral arguments Wednesday. Becky Hill’s perjury in the record. The wrong legal standard potentially applied. And a defense team that now has the entire first trial transcript as a roadmap. Criminal defense attorney Bob Motta joins Hidden Killers to explain what both sides are actually facing if the Alex Murdaugh Read more…
Both ransom deadlines have come and gone. The Bitcoin wallet sits at zero. One demand was a confirmed hoax. The Guthrie family offered to pay six million dollars on camera and nobody collected. For more than a week, the ransom gave this case a framework — pay the money, get Read more…
Multiple ransom notes. A confirmed imposter. A family offering six million in Bitcoin. And absolute silence from whoever may have taken Nancy Guthrie. Criminal defense attorney Bob Motta joins Hidden Killers to walk through what is actually happening in this case nine days after Nancy vanished from her Catalina Foothills Read more…
The most visible operation of the entire Nancy Guthrie investigation collapsed in hours. A 27-year-old delivery driver was detained south of Tucson after allegedly being told he resembled the person in newly released doorbell footage. His mother-in-law’s Rio Rico home was searched under warrant. FBI Evidence Response on scene. He Read more…
Alex Murdaugh’s Supreme Court appeal heads to oral arguments on February 11, 2026. But while the legal world debates whether his double murder conviction will be overturned, almost no one is breaking down the most uncomfortable question in this case — what actually happens if he wins? Murdaugh doesn’t walk Read more…
The Pima County Sheriff says there are no suspects in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie. But deputies spent hours inside a family member’s home conducting forensic photography and left with evidence bags. A vehicle was towed. The septic tank was searched. The FBI took over. Criminal defense attorney Bob Motta Read more…
When Anna Kepner’s sixteen-year-old stepbrother walked into a federal courthouse in Miami facing multiple charges stemming from her death aboard the Carnival Horizon cruise ship, the most telling detail came from Anna’s own father. Christopher Kepner told the Daily Mail he was “unable to confirm or deny” that his stepson Read more…